Patent granted in India to DHANUKA AGRITECH LIMITED — research analysis
Identify the reported Indian Dhanuka patent
The historical GIPResearch article identifies Indian patent 374065 as a grant associated with Dhanuka Agritech Limited and the title Synergistic Herbicidal Formulation Comprising Combination of Halosulfuron Methyl and Metribuzin for Control of Sedges, Narrow and Broad Leaf Weeds in Sugarcane. Dhanuka's publicly available company statement dated 30 October 2021 says that its first patent had been granted on 9 August 2021 for this formulation. A secondary patent listing also connects the title with an application filed in May 2017. These sources support identification of a historical grant, but a current official Indian registry extract is still needed to verify present proprietor, renewal, amended claims and any later challenge. Grant history and current enforceability are different findings.
Source for this point: Dhanuka Agritech — 30 October 2021 company statement (Issuer statement, historical grant date; not current patent register).
Describe the specific claimed technical formulation
The legacy article reports a formulation containing 6% by weight halosulfuron methyl, 50% by weight metribuzin and an agrochemically acceptable excipient, intended for control of specified weeds in sugarcane. This is a much narrower technical identity than 'an agricultural herbicide patent'. A researcher should verify the exact granted independent claim and every numerical range directly from the specification and official prosecution file. The formulation's alleged synergy is another separate question: to demonstrate an effect greater than expected from the individual components, the underlying experiments should state dosages, weed species, crop conditions, controls and the analytical measure of combined effect. Merely mixing two known active agents does not establish synergistic performance.
Separate patent-grant evidence from product approval
A patent grant does not establish that an agricultural chemical is authorized for sale or use under pesticide regulation, nor does a product registration establish that its manufacturer owns every relevant patent. Dhanuka's 2021 corporate statement expressly described the product as undergoing registration at that time. Research should therefore keep patent entitlement, regulatory authorization, field-performance evidence and commercial product identity in separate columns. Further, later judicial materials involving halosulfuron-methyl market registrations concern different regulatory disputes; they should not be treated as litigation about patent 374065 without a direct documentary connection. The central analytical discipline is to resist using one official fact to prove a distinct legal or technical proposition.
Reconstruct claim scope and examination history
The legacy article states that the Indian examiner raised a section 3(d) objection and that the applicant relied on a specific synergistic combination and unexpected weed-control effects. Those arguments require comparison with the actual examination report, applicant reply and final claims. Section 3(e), concerning mere admixture, may also be a relevant statutory question, but the applicable objections should not be invented. A useful prosecution table should list the objection, cited prior art, evidence submitted, claim amendments and the authority's final disposition. Patent protection, if enforceable, depends on the granted claims and claim interpretation, not the broader field description in the patent abstract or the company's investor communication.
Source for this point: IP India — Patents Act 1970, section 3 (Official statute).
Compare the invention with prior herbicide combinations
A landscape study should identify earlier disclosures of each active ingredient, mixtures targeting the same weeds, formulation ratios, application timing and agricultural conditions. Search by chemical name, synonyms, formulation type, crop, target weed and applicant, using patent and non-patent agronomy records. A difference in the specified 6:50 composition may matter, but novelty and inventive step require document-specific comparison. The study should also distinguish formulation patents from patents on active compounds and from registered uses or trademarks. Any claim that the Dhanuka combination achieved a particular field performance should be supported by comparative trial data, including statistical limitations where available.
Establish a traceable legal-status chronology
A proposed chronology begins with the reported May 2017 application, publication history, the reported August 2021 grant and subsequent renewal records. However, the exact filing and grant records must be retrieved from the responsible Indian office. The chronology should record priority details, current proprietor, maintenance evidence, opposition or revocation proceedings if located, and the latest registry inspection date. A commercial data vendor may label a right 'in force', but that field can be stale or derived from assumptions. It should never be the sole basis for advice on enforceability. A transaction-ready dossier includes copies of the relevant official entries and a clear distinction between observed events and unresolved record gaps.
Create a claim-to-agronomy evidence matrix
The first information-gain table should place the reported formulation limitation beside the relevant weed-control experiment: ingredient, weight percentage, acceptable excipients, application mode, weed species, crop context and technical outcome. The second table should list comparable herbicide disclosures, identifying whether they address the same ratio or a different combination. Such a matrix can expose whether the commercially important result depends on a narrow formulation rather than a broad principle of combination treatment. If quantitative performance data cannot be retrieved, the report should explicitly label the claim of synergy as an applicant assertion or unverified historical claim. A patent title alone does not prove a measured effect.
Identify what remains to be verified
The historical patent and corporate sources justify a focused investigation of patent 374065. They do not establish a present freedom-to-operate conclusion, a current exclusive market position, a validated infringement finding or crop safety under current regulation. The final published dossier should require the current grant document, live legal-status record, applicable applicant responses and a technical comparison with real competing formulations. For a buyer or licensee, both patent scope and product registrations would need separate review. The useful immediate output is an evidence register, with confident historical facts separated from open legal-status and technical-performance questions.
Maintain separation between the herbicide and regulatory disputes
An additional diligence check should identify whether later legal disputes involving halosulfuron methyl address this particular formulation patent, a crop-protection registration, an import license or a different commercial right. Similar chemical names and the same corporate participant can produce misleading associations in search results. Record the exact case number, parties, legal issue and disposition before linking any proceeding to patent 374065. For the patent itself, compare reported chemical ratios with the full claims and check whether any dependent claim defines a narrower application mode. This disciplined event mapping can prevent an outdated company press statement from being interpreted as a current authorization to market a product or as evidence of an uncontested patent right.
Original evidence-to-decision matrix
| Research dimension | Evidence to inspect | Interpretation boundary |
|---|---|---|
| Historical grant | Dhanuka 2021 company statement, number 374065 | Current official register status not checked |
| Formulation | 6% halosulfuron methyl; 50% metribuzin | Verify granted independent claim |
| Synergy | Controlled weed-effect experiments | Applicant assertion versus independent proof |
Research readiness checklist
- Retrieve official Indian 374065 grant and current status.
- Verify reported 6:50 ratio from final independent claim.
- Inspect the examination correspondence before reporting objections.
- Separate pesticide regulatory records from patent rights.
References and primary sources
- Dhanuka Agritech — 30 October 2021 company statement. Issuer statement, historical grant date; not current patent register.
- IP India — Patents Act 1970, section 3. Official statute.
- GIPResearch.com — preserved Dhanuka historical article. Original site assertion; not independent patent-office verification.
General research only. Any current grant, claim, ownership, legal status or professional opinion requires verification of official records and the facts of the particular matter. Full disclaimer


How to patent fintech inventions
Gen AI Innovations
What is Extended Reality
How to patent artificial intelligence based innovations
Patent claim drafting