Traditional Knowledge Patent
TK, which stands for Traditional Knowledge refers to the information accumulated and shared by indigenous and local communities through their cultural customs and experiences over time. It is relied on extensively in the promotion of innovation, especially in the chemical business, as it can spur the creation of new forms of drugs, colors, raw food products, and so on. However, the exceptions under traditional knowledge raise paradigmatic issues in the area of IP law protection. This is because contrary to modern innovations, traditional knowledge needs more individual or commercial ownership, while on the other hand, traditional knowledge patents are among the major forms of protection that fail to effectively protect traditional knowledge. This blog will discuss the practical procedures as well as undergo a detailed showing on how to file a patent for traditional knowledge-based chemical innovations by use of best practices and relevant case studies where necessary. It intends to provide innovators and stakeholders with the essential know-how to facilitate the traditional knowledge patent process for the benefit of their innovations.
Understanding Traditional Knowledge and Chemical Innovation
Traditional knowledge can be defined as the body of accumulated academic, social, historical, and cultural knowledge that manifested itself in the indigenous and local communities use of their surrounding environmental context for a long time. traditional knowledge is important with regard to cultural, as well as biological, diversity, with traditional knowledge and practice often reflecting routine, and profound, appreciation of natural resources; medicinal plants, agriculture, and ecological resources. In the context of chemistry, ideas, and innovation, traditional knowledge has been an enlightening and working model. One example would be herbal medicines that are in the form of plant preparations, natural dyes that are obtained from native sources, and biocontrol agents such as bio-pesticides.
The mentioned innovations illustrate how traditional knowledge and science also go hand in hand, by offering ecological and appropriate solutions to contemporary problems. The arguments for the need to protect TK-based innovations through patents include the following: It also ensures that the owners of the resources receive due credit, and protects the communities against biopiracy while encouraging innovation in the use of the resources. But even this protection becomes complicated by the complexities of patent law systems bearing in mind that there are differences in the epistemology of modern indigenous knowledge and those in the past.
Patenting aspects of traditional knowledge and natural products
Traditional knowledge patents and natural products involve challenges like proving originality and avoiding biopiracy. Often communal and undocumented, traditional knowledge may invalidate patent claims due to prior art. Legal frameworks like the CBD and Nagoya Protocol promote fair benefit-sharing. Documenting traditional knowledge in databases, such as India’s TKDL, helps prevent biopiracy. Balancing intellectual property rights with protecting and equitably sharing traditional knowledge is crucial.
Patentability Criteria for TK-Based Chemical Innovations
Novelty
The innovation must be new and not previously disclosed in any form, including within the traditional knowledge system itself. This often requires comprehensive documentation to prove that the knowledge has not been previously published or used.
Inventive Step
The innovation should involve a non-obvious technical advance. For TK-based innovations, this means demonstrating that the development goes beyond the existing traditional knowledge and provides a significant improvement.
Industrial Applicability
The innovation must be applicable in an industry, meaning it can be produced or used in a practical, commercial context. This criterion ensures that the innovation has tangible benefits and utility.
Subject Matter Eligibility
Traditional knowledge-based innovations, particularly those for conventional herbs, might encounter difficulties in qualifying for the criteria of an invention that can be patented. To achieve this it is necessary to work with a framing or ‘carrying case’ of innovation that focuses on the technical and industrial potential of the innovation instead of just the conventional application.
Documenting and Digitizing Traditional Knowledge
For the purpose of providing the necessary legal protection and ensuring proper traditional knowledge protection, documentation and digitization processes are very important. Documents that are accurate are able to support novelty and enable traditional knowledge patent applications. There are several efforts to make it as smooth as the Traditional Knowledge Digital Library (TKDL) in India where all this knowledge base is being translated systematically into patentable forms. The whole process of documenting traditional knowledge has various constraints, for example, misappropriation, loss of context, and cultural sensitivity. Some of the common guidelines when documenting traditional knowledge are the active involvement of the community and its members, acknowledging professional and cultural responsibilities, and gaining permission from the indigenous people when recording and disseminating the knowledge. Digitization must also pay adequate attention to the database where the information of TK holders is to be stored in order to ensure the security of such holders.
Drafting the Patent Application
Involving patent agents or attorneys with expertise in traditional knowledge (TK) and chemical innovations is crucial for navigating traditional knowledge patent applications. Key components include:
Description
This section provides a detailed explanation of the innovation, including technical aspects like chemical processes and methodologies derived from TK. For example, a medicinal formulation should describe the plant species, extraction techniques, and chemical compounds. It must also demonstrate industrial applicability for sectors like pharmaceuticals and agriculture.
Claims
The claims section defines the legal scope of the patent protection. It includes specific legal statements outlining the unique features of the innovation, aiming for the broadest scope without overlapping prior art. Claims should include independent and dependent claims for comprehensive coverage.
Drawings
Visual representations enhance understanding. Detailed technical illustrations, such as diagrams of chemical structures, processes, or apparatus used, should be included. Accurate visuals support the claims and descriptions, aiding in explaining complex aspects.
Disclosure Requirements
Full disclosure ensures transparency, enabling replication of the innovation. This section should provide complete information, including limitations, variations, and best practices. Citing prior art establishes novelty and distinguishes the innovation from existing knowledge.
Benefit-Sharing Arrangements
These ensure benefits are shared with the communities from which the TK originated. Arrangements might include monetary compensation, joint ventures, or technology transfers. Clearly outlining these in the traditional knowledge patent application demonstrates ethical practices, gaining support from indigenous communities and ensuring they are recognized and rewarded.
Filing the Traditional Knowledge Patent Application
It is important to note that there are national, regional, and international patent offices, and one must consider which to apply to under the market they plan to target and overall business strategy. Most patent offices provide online filing and general, simple ways of applying for patents to inventors. There could also be other charges that the patent holder has to pay to keep and maintain the traditional knowledge patent, and these charges could be significantly different depending on the country.
Post-Filing Considerations
The preparation of filing an application to be granted is very important but it is also important to to prepare for the patent office actions and examinations after the filing. This may involve replying to questions, elaborating on the documentation provided, or fine-tuning the claims that are submitted to the authority. The pre- and post-grant opposition procedures enable any third party to oppose the enveloped patent, and therefore it is important to have a strong defense mechanism. Another area of significant importance is defending the patented innovation from infringement, which may need the use of the law to prosecute the infringement.
Case Studies and Examples of Traditional Knowledge and Patents
Successful examples of patented traditional knowledge-based chemical innovations illustrate the potential and challenges of this endeavor. Notable cases include:
Turmeric: Successfully patented for its wound-healing properties, although the patent was later revoked due to prior art in traditional knowledge.
Neem: Patented for its pesticidal properties, which faced opposition but ultimately reinforced the importance of traditional knowledge documentation.
Basmati Rice: Highlighted the complexities of biopiracy and the need for stringent IP protection mechanisms.
Patent for Traditional Knowledge Chemical Innovation
To integrate indigenous knowledge and innovations into the general body of chemical innovations, the use of traditional knowledge patents as forms of protection for TK-based chemical innovations is critical for acknowledging the importance of indigenous and local community contributions in the advancement of science and technology. It involves documentation, better coordination, and organizational development among all the stakeholders involved in ESF. Suppose we want to avoid numerous pitfalls that ontological traditional knowledge experiences nowadays, and maintain its power as a source of inspiration for further chemical developments that will be beneficial for both the owners of prior knowledge and humanity. In that case, we need to use the capacities of the patent system more efficiently. Stakeholders, governments, other parties, leaders, organizations, institutions, and various communities at large need to collaborate to foster an alternate copyright regime and respect and incorporate the IP of indigenous knowledge.
Our team of advanced patent attorneys assists clients with patent searches, drafting patent applications, and patent (intellectual property) agreements, including licensing and non-disclosure agreements.
Advocate Rahul Dev is a Patent Attorney & International Business Lawyer practicing Technology, Intellectual Property & Corporate Laws. He is reachable at rd (at) patentbusinesslawyer (dot) com & @rdpatentlawyer on Twitter.
Quoted in and contributed to 50+ national & international publications (Bloomberg, FirstPost, SwissInfo, Outlook Money, Yahoo News, Times of India, Economic Times, Business Standard, Quartz, Global Legal Post, International Bar Association, LawAsia, BioSpectrum Asia, Digital News Asia, e27, Leaders Speak, Entrepreneur India, VCCircle, AutoTech).
Regularly invited to speak at international & national platforms (conferences, TV channels, seminars, corporate trainings, government workshops) on technology, patents, business strategy, legal developments, leadership & management.
Working closely with patent attorneys along with international law firms with significant experience with lawyers in Asia Pacific providing services to clients in US and Europe. Flagship services include international patent and trademark filings, patent services in India and global patent consulting services.
Global Blockchain Lawyers (www.GlobalBlockchainLawyers.com) is a digital platform to discuss legal issues, latest technology and legal developments, and applicable laws in the dynamic field of Digital Currency, blockchain, Bitcoin, Cryptocurrency and raising capital through the sale of tokens or coins (ICO or Initial Coin Offerings).
Blockchain ecosystem in India is evolving at a rapid pace and a proactive legal approach is required by blockchain lawyers in India to understand the complex nature of applicable laws and regulations
